• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Frosty Moose: Delicious Sandwiches & Premium Ice Cream in Williams Bay, WI

Frosty Moose, nestled in Williams Bay, WI, is a local gem renowned for its hearty sandwiches and rich ice cream. Their sandwiches, generously packed with quality meat, cheese, and fresh veggies, satisfy every craving—from meat lovers to vegetarians. The ice cream, available in a wide array of flavors like Oreo and butter pecan, offers a perfect sweet finish or refreshing treat on warm days. Friendly staff and a charming patio add to the welcoming atmosphere, making it an ideal spot for lunch or a casual hangout. Frosty Moose combines flavor, quality, and community spirit with every bite and scoop.

Frosty Moose at a glance

  • Address 35 W Geneva St, Williams Bay, WI 53191, United States
  • Phone +1 262-245-2445
  • Restaurant type Ice cream shop , Fast food restaurant , Takeout restaurant , Sandwich shop .

Photos & Gallery

Frosty Moose: Reviews & Ratings

Karen Milligan
5

Sandwiches were super packed with meat and cheese .... delicious! We then got ice cream...great quality for a decent price.

Amanda Drews
5

Great spot for sandwiches and ice cream. Tons of flavors to choose from with a great Oreo one. Nice patio off to the side.

Mylla P
5

Stopped to check out on Sandwichs. As a vegetarian, it is hard to find good options. Got an egg salad sandwich, and it comes with cheese and veggies. Grabbed an ice cream butter pecan on a chocolate cone as well. Perfect for the hot day. Took my sandwich to go so I could enjoy it at the pool. I'm definitely coming back as it's close by my home.

Wil Eitel
5

We stopped in for some lunch on a beautiful June Saturday. Everything was fantastic, from the service to the food to the atmosphere - and then we topped it off with ice cream. I enjoyed the best malt I've had in decades! Will definitely be back.

Byron Straughn
5

Due to weather we had to change our group's evening plans. Two of us stopped by the Frosty Moose (without warning) to buy ice cream for our very large group. The owners and staff were incredibly accommodating, providing us advice about flavors for kids and adults, but also providing us with timely service. They went above and beyond what I expected and everyone loved the ice cream. They seem like a golden business.

Ryan Yantis
5

Great sandwiches, wraps & service. We've loved everything so far, with the Ceasar Chicken Wrap and the Corned Beef being outstanding. HUGE single scoop ice cream - great flavors.

Esther
5

There was plenty of meat in my roast beef sandwich and you get your choice of condiments, very fresh. All in all, a flavorful combo. I also got a huge scoop of praline pecan. I apologize, I enjoyed about half of the food before I took a picture. It was that good. Enjoy it while it lasts, though... I was told they close for the season around Halloween.

Eileen Chapuis
5

Delicious ice cream and attentive service! Prices are truly fair!

Location

  • Frosty Moose
    Frosty Moose
    35 W Geneva St, Williams Bay, WI 53191, United States Hotline: +1 262-245-2445

Frosty Moose, nestled in the heart of Williams Bay, Wisconsin, is much more than your average ice cream shop. Located at 35 W Geneva St, this local gem masterfully blends hearty deli-style sandwiches with a vibrant assortment of creamy ice cream treats. Whether you’re craving a robust Roast Beef or a savory Egg Salad Sandwich, Frosty Moose delivers generous portions packed with rich flavors and satisfying textures that leave a lasting impression.

The Prairie Dirt Sundae stands out as a delightful signature dessert—an indulgent combination that complements their savory menu perfectly. Ice cream lovers have abundant choices here, from classic Ice Cream Cones and Crunch Cones to cups bearing enticing flavors like Butter Pecan atop a chocolate cone. The quality of their ice cream is exceptional, striking a perfect balance between creaminess and flavor depth, all offered at reasonable prices.

What truly elevates the Frosty Moose experience is the warm and attentive service paired with a welcoming atmosphere, including a charming side patio that invites guests to linger and enjoy their meal in comfort. Reviewers consistently highlight the accommodating staff and the freshness and generosity of the sandwiches, as well as the thoughtfully curated ice cream selection, which features crowd favorites like Oreo.

Vegetarian options, such as the egg salad sandwich with cheese and fresh veggies, cater well to diverse diets without sacrificing taste or satisfaction. It’s the kind of spot that feels both neighborly and special, appealing to families, solo visitors, and groups alike. Whether stopping by for a quick lunch on a sunny afternoon or gathering for a sweet treat, Frosty Moose offers genuine delight in every bite and scoop.

Business Information

  • Accessibility
    • Wheelchair-accessible car park
    • Wheelchair-accessible entrance
  • Service options
    • Takeaway
    • Same-day delivery
  • Payments
    • Credit cards
    • Debit cards
    • NFC mobile payments